puterbonga4 hours ago
Every time someone does a project like this, it exposes how trivial “IoT” really is once you strip away vendor lock in and buzzwords. A $3 sensor, a 10 line script, and a 40 year old ham protocol outperform half the commercial weather APIs out there.
seemaze38 minutes ago
To be generous, this solution 'outperforms' commercial weather APIs for exactly one hyperlocal geographic location, and underperforms on 99.999999% of the remaining locations that may also be experiencing weather of some sort.
XorNot3 hours ago
There's a magical world out there where Tuya leave us with the ability to OTA flash custom firmware of we have physical access, and then we can all just run ESPHome on private wifi networks.
dylan6042 hours ago
And what recovery mechanisms do you have in place when the OTA flash goes wrong?
kobalsky34 minutes ago
you can have 2 identical partitions on the ESP, the OTA flashes the inactive partition and signals to bootloader to attempt to boot it from there.

the device is restarted, if the new firmware is working correctly you signal the update process that everything is all right and it sets the new partition as default.

if the device doesn't boot correctly, or your sanity checks don't pass, either you or the watchdog restarts the device and it boot from the known-working partition.

yapyap1 hour ago
same recovery mechanism as when the Crowdstrike OTA goes wrong
alentred2 hours ago
With respect, this misses some important constraints. Scale it to thousands of locations and target 99% SLA. Now you have a maintenance problem in remote physical places, requirements for hardware reliability, subcontractors to manage, need a reliable network connectivity, etc. You also need to collect and redistribute the data (API or whatever) - while this is a trivial problem today, still you incur costs for hosting, network, etc. While I actually agree with the sentiment, it is not just a $3 sensor either.
Thev00d007 hours ago
"If you want to support me, send me AA batteries" in the bot account profile made me chuckle.
dn35007 hours ago
You might consider joining the Citizen Weather Observer Program. It's a great way to share your data with other station owners.

http://www.wxqa.com/

I had a station for a few years. The receiver had a usb interface so no software radio required. I used weewx to import the data. I even had a water temperature sensor off the end of my dock so I could see if the lake was warm enough to swim in.

Havoc57 minutes ago
Uk weather office has a similar effort apparently - select registered sites and disable the official ones here:

https://wow.metoffice.gov.uk/

Interesting to see that it gets many submissions from outside UK too

WaitWaitWha3 hours ago
Slightly tangential, my hope is that the Blitzortung project picks up momentum.

> Blitzortung.org and Lightningmaps.org are world-wide non-commercial low-cost community-based lightning detection and lightning location networks. They provide free real time lightning maps for a lot of count

[docs of the projects](https://docs.lightningmaps.org)

[real-time lightening map](https://map.blitzortung.org)

Havoc58 minutes ago
Been meaning to DIY a weather solution too...just need to figure out how to power it on balcony (no power). Thinking perhaps via the new sodium batteries & explore that too while at it.
seemaze44 minutes ago
If you live in a moderately dense area or know a neighbor who also has a weather station, you might try the command line utility rtl_433[0] mentioned in the article with an SDR dongle to pick up existing broadcasts in your area. I pick up three different stations consistently!

[0]https://github.com/merbanan/rtl_433

the_gipsy6 hours ago
I want to do the reverse: I have a DIY esp32 "weather" station (temp/humidity but more importantly particle sensor) and I would love to share it via radio!
xd19361 hour ago
I was very grateful to the author for `aprs-weather-submit` while building cwop.rest. Great post.
eternauta3k7 hours ago
Holy cow, cheap weather stations are encoding and decoding JSON? What a century.
mungoman27 hours ago
No, the tool rtl_433 repackages payload data in json for easier downstream consumption.
digitalsushi3 hours ago
my winter project is to create a container pod at home that remixes media, maybe adds in some old or joke tv commercials between shows, and most importantly, shows the weather and the route to work at 7am. i think everything exists to do this, but it might take a few weeks to cobble together.
auspiv1 hour ago
For even more retro points, have the UI presented by WeatherStar! https://weatherstar.netbymatt.com/
brna-28 hours ago
I was kinda expecting analogue tech and computer vision here. :D Nice work.
dylan6041 hour ago
The very first cable weather "channel" was a large circular base at least 4' diameter (don't remember exact size, but big) that had various full size gauges on it. A camera was positioned to look down on the gauge under it. The whole table top rotated so that each gauge would continuously cycle under the camera. When you viewed the channel, you'd have to wait until the gauge you wanted to see rotated back around.
phito7 hours ago
Cool project but I would just have used a zigbee/wifi weather station, they are just as cheap.
3D304974206 hours ago
I get the sense from the article that part of the fun was doing this via radio frequencies rather than having to deal with a network.

> At this point, we've connected the Temu weather station to the Internet and the ham radio network. Anyone with an APRS-enabled radio, digipeater, receiver, or just a web browser can see what the temperature and humidity are at my house.

0xbadcafebee1 hour ago
links? the closest thing is 10x the price, some are more like $80, some $180
defraudbah4 hours ago
this is one of the most fascinating and funniest articles i've read in a while
Tepix4 hours ago
I expected "putting something on the internet" to mean being to talk to a device directly, not taking its data and publishing it somewhere. Is it just me?
IAmBroom3 hours ago
Yes.